January Dawn

Sunday, June 13, 2010

Chapter 28 In the Closet

Through the summer Ruth spent more time at the Center. She and I teased Colin about Anna, a single woman who worked for the Nurse’s Registry. We had tried to get him interested in other women occasionally, but Anna lived in the building. She worked there. She was available. She was nice. Why didn’t he take her out? Sometimes he acted a little sore at our teasing. But we didn’t stop.

By late September, I have given in to Ruth’s allure. She was my girlfriend. In October, I returned to the apartment on a Sunday evening after spending the day with Ruth. Colin, as usual, wanted to hear about my day. He was always cheering us on.
I asked him about Anna again. Why didn’t he date her . . . or someone? “You’re always talking about how nice it would be to have a woman in your life, why don’t you do something about it? It’s not like there aren’t any available women. If you’re not interested in Anna, what about Pauline or Linda?”

He didn’t answer immediately. When he did, he spoke with uncharacteristic hesitancy. “Listen, Johnny, I think it’s time to tell you why I’m single. Why I don’t date Anna or Emily or Pauline. I don’t want to hurt them. It just wouldn’t work out.
“When I was growing up in England, my mother was very strong. She ran my dad around like he was a child. And, of course, polio strongly affected my sense of who I was. I couldn’t compete with the other kids physically, so I became a voracious reader. I got into the occult.

“Then I saw an advertisement for some a lecture on flying saucers. I went and was shocked to discover that it was a religious meeting. But I got hooked and I attended every meeting. My parents didn’t have any particular religion so they didn’t mind when I decided to get baptized.

“I loved the prophecies and learning about God. But even as I was getting more and more involved in church, I was troubled by the growing realization that I did not like women the way other boys did.

“The preacher at our church encouraged me to go to Newbold College. He said that was the place to meet nice Adventist girls. So I went. And I went out with girls there, very nice girls. I even kissed a few of them. But there was nothing in my heart that responded.

“I talked with one of the religion professors. He told me to just find a nice girl who played the piano and marry her and everything would work out in time. I tried. I dated one girl for over a year, but as much as I enjoyed her as a friend, I just could not see being married to her.

“After I graduated from Newbold, I worked as a pastor for a few years, then came to Andrews to get my masters. There, I really faced this thing. I fasted and prayed. I had friends who fasted and prayed with me. One time I felt this utter confidence that God was going to heal me. I asked to be a anointed. In preparation, I spent a week fasting and praying. The anointing was held on Friday night. I had a girlfriend. She was there. Three seminary professors and several of my classmates participated. We spent an hour praying before they finally anointed me and claimed God’s promises of transformation and new life.

“I went to bed utterly euphoric.

“I picked up Wanda the next morning and we went to church together. The whole world was bright. I was healed. I was normal. I was a heterosexual. At the end of the day I kissed her. It was wonderful.

“But a couple of weeks later the old feelings were back. Wanda begged me not to worry about it. We could work on it together, she insisted. But it just wasn’t right to marry someone you didn’t have feelings for. I mean sexual desire. She was sweet. I liked her. But it just wasn’t there.

“Later at Andrews a group performed an exorcism on me. They believed homosexual impulses were a form of demon possession. Again, for a couple of weeks, I felt different. But it didn’t last.

“So I’m committed to a life of celibacy–unless God heals me. I still pray every day to be changed. But there you have it old boy. That’s why I don’t date Anna. That’s why I get upset when you and Ruth tease me.”

I was stunned. What would it be like to be trapped in a prison like that? I was mad at God for all the conflict I felt over Ruth, but that was just because she was the wrong race and this was the wrong time in my life for a serious relationship. What would it be like to know you could never have a wife? Never have someone to sleep with, have sex with, raise a family with, grow old with?

I had prayed for a bicycle, and money miraculously showed up. Colin prayed for healing from homosexuality. He fasted and prayed. He was anointed. He had an exorcism. He had tried everything imaginable to obtain God’s power to change so he could live the life God wanted him to live. And it didn’t work. Why would God condemn people for something there was no healing for?

I had picked up from church culture the assumption that homosexuals were people who made bad choices. Just like alcoholics or smokers. They might have a hard time altering their behavior, but if they would simply choose to do the right thing, they could. Of course, like all temptations, homosexual temptation could be resisted only with the help of God. But certainly that help was available. Now, I couldn’t be so sure. God didn’t show up to help Colin.

I didn’t know where this left the Bible’s bold claims. It talked glibly about God’s power. “No temptation has befallen you, except what is common to all men. And God will, with the temptation, make available a way of escape.” “God is at work in you both to will and to do of his good pleasure.” “I can do all things through Christ who strengthens me.”

I knew my moral failures were my own fault. I had no excuse. I simply made bad choices–choices that were not inevitable, choices that could have been different if I had taken more time to pray and read my Bible. Listening to Colin, I could not imagine what more he could have done. If that was true, how could I as a preacher stand up and tell people about the power of God, when apparently it did not work in the lives of homosexuals?


I flew home for Christmas, then returned to New York for a weekend before leaving for Middle East College in Beirut, Lebanon.

Going to MEC was a lark. In September, someone had stayed at the Center for a couple of days to visit a girl who worked there. He was an American, returning for a second year at MEC. He loved it. Said it was easy to get accepted and easy to transfer credits back to Adventist colleges in the U.S. Why didn't I come when my year at the Center was up in December. Sure. Why not?

On Sunday of that last weekend back in New York, as Ruth and I were walking east on 46th Street away from The Center toward Avenue of the Americas to catch the “Train to the Plane,” the subway/bus system connecting Manhattan and JFK Airport, we met Benny coming toward us. He was drunk and wanted to talk. I explained I had a plane to catch. I couldn’t talk now. He shifted back and forth across the sidewalk determined to keep us from passing. I called to a policeman who happened to be standing not far away.

“Officer, can you help us?”

“What’s the trouble?”

“This guy won’t let us walk down the sidewalk. I’ve got a plane to catch.”

“You want me to arrest you?” The policeman challenged Benny sharply. “Get over against that wall.”

“But officer . . .”

“Shut up and get over against that wall.” Benny complied.

I thanked the policeman and we continued east. A minute later I looked back. Benny was staggering toward Times Square.

I first met Benny when he was newly arrived from Alabama, the son of a southern Pentecostal preacher. No job, but determined to find one and make a new life for himself far away from the stifling world of his childhood. He had attended Bible studies in the Ark occasionally. Then he started coming in drunk. After that I’d meet him on the street occasionally, obviously drunk, apparently homeless. Nothing I could say had the slightest affect on his addiction.

Other people could tell their stories of God’s miraculous intervention. They could talk about times when God clearly broke through and demonstrated his power through them. I remembered someone telling me about an Adventist preacher who took seriously our prophet's counsel about personal involvement with the unfortunate. This preacher took a homeless alcoholic into his home. Had the man accompany him everywhere he went–to conference committee meetings, to preaching appointments. Eventually, the man got his life straightened out, got a job, returned to his estranged wife.

The best I could do was witness a tragic slide into oblivion.

At JFK, I checked in, then Ruth and I walked out to the gate. We sat, holding hands, waiting for my flight to start boarding, already feeling the ache of separation.

Chapter 27 Times Square

I admired Colin–his fiery preaching, his bold, almost reckless forwardness in presenting himself and his ideas. But he got on my nerves in a way I could not make sense of. I couldn’t stand to have him near me, especially in the apartment. We bickered constantly. I felt guilty. It was his apartment. He was the minister. I was supposed to be helping him. I suspected I instead made his work harder. Ruth liked him. Everyone around me liked him. I couldn’t understand what was wrong with me.

The immediate environment of the Center didn’t help. It was several blocks to any of the four subway stations in the area. If I wore a suit, while walking between the Center and the subway in the evening, women in tiny skirts and tight tops called out, “Want a date?” If I wore casual clothes it was not uncommon for middle aged men to walk along side me and ask if they could buy me coffee. The first time a man used this line, I was handing out fliers on the street. I was thrilled thinking he had read the flier and was interested. Here was a divine appointment, an opportunity to share my faith. We walked to a small shop in the next block. I ordered hot chocolate, which he paid for, and we sat at a table on the street talking for more than ten minutes before I realized he, too, was “looking for a date.” I was deeply embarrassed, annoyed and a little smarter.

I learned to walk with a fierce directness. It violated both my instincts and my culture. I am addicted to people. I need them to smile at me. I want to connect with them. Besides, my Southern heritage placed an enormous value on courtesy. One was always pleasant in face-to-face encounters, even if privately you despised the person you were interacting with. But in Times Square courtesy toward strangers would be misinterpreted. Eye-contact was a violation of the social contract, unless one was prepared to do business. So every time I walked from the subway to the apartment, especially in the evening, I put on an artificial brusqueness. My body language had to say, don’t touch me, don’t talk to me, don’t notice me. I hated it. At the Center, I would ride the elevator to the sixth floor and walk to the apartment hoping Colin wasn’t there. Inside, Colin would look up from his reading with his enormous eyes. “How was it old boy? Welcome home!” I would tense. He wanted conversation. I knew of no courteous way to avoid it.

There was nowhere to be at ease. No where to rest. Except with Ruth. She asked nothing. Demanded nothing. Just seemed to enjoy hanging around.

God didn’t want me to date Ruth. I was sure of that. I knew my parents would not approve of my marrying someone who wasn’t White. Besides that, I wasn’t planning to marry until after grad school and that was a long time from now. There was no way I could date someone that long. So why date someone when breaking up was inevitable? Why should I bruise someone’s heart on purpose?

So I resisted–not her. She never pushed. I was resisting my own desperate craving for connection and sweetness and warmth and beauty. I complained bitterly to God in prayer: Why dangle her in front of me and forbid me to touch her?

My pay was 175 dollars a month plus free rent. I gave twenty percent to the church and paid for my travel and food and incidentals out of what was left. Not long after I arrived, I realized I did not have a coat adequate for the New York winter. Mrs. Toby gave me one she had received from somewhere. It seemed miraculous.
In the spring, I began to think of getting a bicycle for getting around Manhattan. This would save subway fare and give me some exercise. But how was I going to afford it? I could always call home and ask for money, but that seemed like a violation of the missionary venture. So I prayed.

A couple of weeks later, I received a check for a hundred twenty dollars for work I had done more than a year earlier. I bought a used bike. It was wonderful. It opened the city for me. On the bicycle I could traverse midtown faster than a taxi. The exercise eased the stress of living with Colin and pining for Ruth.



I lived in constant depression. My daily prayer time consisted of mournful, desperate pleas to heaven for help. I wasn’t sure exactly what kind of help I needed. I prayed for evidence that I was actually in God’s service. I wanted to see people changed. I prayed for a better attitude toward Colin. I prayed about Ruth.
Late in the summer I happened to weigh myself. I had lost thirty pounds. I could afford to lose it. But the loss startled me. I must be worse off than I thought.

One afternoon in August, a friend stopped by the Center. He was depressed and discouraged. We sat and talked for a couple of hours. I see the light coming back into his eyes. He left buoyant. I dragged myself upstairs and collapsed on my bed. I could heal others but could not help myself. Where was God? I was supposed to be an evangelist. My job was to persuade others to come join us, to believe what we believed, to live the way we lived. But why would I want anyone else to join a religion that was making me miserable? Our prophet had written that the greatest form of evangelism was to tell others what Jesus had done for me. But Jesus was making me miserable.

My evangelistic duties did bring enjoyment, at times. Just a couple of blocks west of the Center were the brownstone houses of Hell’s Kitchen. Three to six story walk ups. Cracked side walks. Stoops a couple of steps up from the street. I was responsible for knocking on doors there, to invite them to The Ark, to share with them gospel literature.

People opened their doors, welcomed my visits. I reveled in the rawness of their lives, the openness of their conversation. But there were no conversions.

Chapter 26 Ruth

With the end of school, Ruth began attending the Friday night Bible studies I led at Ark. I occasionally asked others in the group to lead it. When I asked Ruth if she would like to lead, she surprised me by saying yes.

The following Friday night, she gave a study on the Sabbath. I was astonished at her approach. She used none of the Bible passages commonly cited by Adventists in our promotion of Sabbath-keeping. Instead Ruth had us read passages from the Psalms and elsewhere that voiced praise to God for his work in creation and in rescuing people from all kinds of difficulties. As Ruth wrapped up her presentation, she said Sabbath was about remembering the good things that come from God’s work of Creation and Redemption.

I was blown away. All the Adventist discourse about Sabbath-keeping I had ever heard focused on either arguments about which day–Saturday or Sunday–was the right day or what was permitted and prohibited on the Sabbath. Well, that and arguments about the role Sabbath would play in testing the spiritual loyalty of people in the last days. Ruth brushed past all that and turned Sabbath into an occasion for worship.
One Friday, our meeting went quite late. We didn’t quit until ten o’clock. Colin was there that evening. As we were breaking up the meeting, Colin expressed concern about Ruth taking the subway to Brooklyn alone at that hour of the night.

“Oh, don’t be silly.” she laughingly protested to him. “I’ve ridden the subway all my life.”

“But, at this hour of the night? I don’t think Willie would be too happy for you to be riding by yourself this late." Colin turned to me. “Johnny why don’t you take her home?”

“Sure, I’d be happy to do that.”

“No, you can’t.” Ruth sputtered. “You won’t get home until midnight.”

“Which precisely makes our point. It’s late. You will be riding the subway and getting off in Park Slope at 11:00 p.m. You need someone with you.”

“You guys are being silly. You’re acting like mother hens.”

“Yes, but we’ll feel better if we know you are safely home." I said. "I’m going with you.”

Ruth and I walked through Times Square to the subway. We sat together on the bench seat. Our hands in our laps, our arms not quite touching. The sense of her closeness was intoxicating. We talked about her father who was a sailor and gone from home months at a time. I learned about her excursions with her brothers into upstate New York looking for bonsai specimens along rocky ridges. She was more and more fascinating.

We exited the subway and walked the six blocks to her house. It was classic Brooklyn, shops on the ground floor along Prospect Ave. Three- and four-story brownstones on the side streets. Trash cans at the curb. People on the sidewalks. Not a lot at that hour, but enough to make the place feel populated, friendly.
I said good night and watched her climb the steps to her front door. She didn’t look back. Once she was inside, I turned to walk to the subway, dizzy with desire and confused guilt because of the desire. I had no business getting involved with her.

Chapter 25 Colin's Disciples

Colin had collected a group of disciples–two couples who had joined the church through his ministry and another couple also fairly new to Adventism. They eagerly attended his Bible studies and became his allies in thinking and dreaming about an expansive ministry. A Filipino family was also an important part of Colin’s social circle in the church. The two Almario brothers were bright and energetic. Their mother considered Colin another of her sons. Their baby sister, Ruth, was a high school junior.

Ruth was quiet. To me she seemed shy, but as I watched her interact with others I was frequently surprised by her confidence and boldness. After awhile it seemed every time Colin did anything with his group Ruth was there. She hung on his every word. She took notes when he preached or taught classes. She was intensely devout.
She never gave the slightest indication that she was interested in me. But I couldn’t help but notice her. She was always there. She was the only person around who was younger than I. In conversation with me, she was always grave, serious, shy. But interacting with everyone else around me, her eyes sparkled. She laughed. She touched people. She teased them.

In March, Calvin headed back to school. That left Colin and me in the apartment. Five evenings a week, I stood on the street usually on Seventh Avenue, near 46th Street, handing out cards inviting people to “The Ark” for Bible studies at seven o’clock. The Ark was our name for the large meeting room in the basement of the Center. I’d hand out cards for a couple of hours until just before seven o’clock, hurry back to the Center to wait hopefully for people to show up, then go back out on the street from eight to ten p.m. Occasionally, someone would come in.
On Friday evenings, we often met with Colin’s disciples. Ollie was a tough, forceful Black man, a singer. His wife was a good looking blond. They often arrived separately coming straight from their jobs. They always greeted each other with a kiss. I wasn’t used to seeing people kiss on the lips. That wasn’t done publicly in our clan. And for sure I wasn’t used to seeing Black men kiss blond women. But they seemed happy enough.

Henry was thin and gentle with a very white face and wispy black hair. He wasn’t short, but his wife was four inches taller, blond and animated.
The other couple was the Barbers. He worked as a minor functionary at a bank. She taught high school.

They all revered Colin. They sometimes talked of creating a retreat center where people could come for extended periods to study under Colin’s tutelage. This dream of a retreat center was fueled in part by the people who attended our monthly smoking cessation clinics.

The Five-day Plan had been created by an Adventist minister and doctor in New England a few years earlier. We ran the program the first week every month at the Center. Mrs. Toby registered the people. Miss Harding made sure we had all the requisite supplies on hand–magazines and pamphlets, the pocket-sized syllabus inserts for each evening that outlined the strategy for that particular day.
Each evening, the program began with a film. The first film featured a lung cancer operation. We wanted people to go home that evening and clear all cigarettes out of their homes and cars. There was no better time to quit than right now. We asked the participants to fast for the first twenty-four hours, drinking only water and fruit juice. If they had to eat something, we wanted them to limit it to carrot and celery sticks and apple slices.

Following the film, each evening featured a presentation on physiology by a health professional and a short lecture on psychology by Colin. Sometimes Mrs. Croft helped us with the health lecture, but our mainstay was a Dr. Jones who drove all the way from Reading, Pennsylvania. He was a captivating speaker. His credentials as an M. D. helped our credibility. My job was to circulate among the class members and be friendly. From the second night on, just before we closed the meeting, we had the class break into small groups to talk about their experience in quitting. I was asked to chair one of these groups. I knew nothing about smoking and even less about quitting. These people were all old enough to be my parents, some old enough to be my grandparents. My leading a group seemed preposterous. Colin insisted, so I did it. I read all the material trying to learn all I could. By the end of the week fifty to eighty percent of the people reported they had successfully quit. That was cool.



Beginning in May with good weather, Colin had me go with him to Battery Park several days a week to do street preaching to the lunch time crowds. Colin would preach; I would stand and listen as “audience bait.” Then, if other people stopped to listen, I would hand out literature, including cards advertising “The Ark.”

I envied Colin his daring, his brashness. Sure, Battery Park had a tradition of street preaching. At the lunch hour in good weather, the park was jammed with people. Sometimes as many as five or six difference speakers would be holding forth at different places in the park–Christian preachers, Jewish preachers, socialists, atheists, right-wing conspiracy theorists. But I couldn’t imagine standing up and shouting at a milling crowd of indifferent strangers.
Colin kept bugging me to try it. “Come on, Johnny, my boy. No one’s going to hurt you.”

I wanted to do it. It seemed so quintessentially Christian. I remembered stories of Joseph Wolff, a converted Jew, who traveled throughout the Middle East and Central Asia in the late 1800s, talking of Jesus to all sorts of people whenever he could get an audience. I recalled stories of native preachers in interior China who would stand and preach on market days. These evangelists preached through storms of rotten produce and sometimes stones. What was I risking? People not stopping to listen?
I resisted, figuring I was already doing my part by helping Colin. Besides I had no idea how to preach in three minute segments. To be an effective street preacher you couldn’t presume a stationary audience for a thirty minute sermon. People were constantly drifting in and out. Your preaching had to have enough progression to keep the interest of people who had been standing there awhile. At the same time newcomers had to be able to pick up an intelligible train of thought immediately.
I finally tried it once. For ten minutes. Crowds did not gather. I did not try it again. But I continued to feel guilty for my lack of courage, my unwillingness to be a fool for Jesus.